Look, this isn’t about winning. It’s about eating. Both methods are awesome for different reasons. Roasted for a snacky, nostalgic treat. Boiled for a comforting, soft addition to a meal.
Fun fact: In Japan, they boil chestnuts (called kuri) and mash them into sweets. In Italy, they roast them over open fires. Two cultures, two textures, both brilliant.
So, try both. Right now. Score some nuts, pop them in the oven. Boil a bowlful for a rainy day. Become a chestnut scientist. Eat the evidence.
One last weird thing: Chestnuts are not true nuts. They’re actually seeds from a tree in the beech family. Mind blown? Mine too. So next time you eat one, you’re eating a fancy tree baby. Boiled or roasted, it’s still a delicious little miracle.
Now go forth. Boil. Roast. Or cheat and buy them pre-cooked from a jar. No judgment. Just chestnut joy.